2004 Annual Reviewer Report

Dec 15, 2004

Yearly, I evaluate Am J Health Behav reviewers for their response time and quality of reviews. Moreover, persons who have not been responsive, repeatedly late, or have chosen not to continue to review manuscripts are removed as reviewers.

In 2004, 14 reviewers were removed. Ten persons removed were from the back cover (Review Board); however, this time around 4 persons from the front inside cover (Editorial Board Members) were removed.

Based on their response time, quality of reviews, and that they are members of the American Academy of Health Behavior:

Amanda S. Birnbaum, Weill Cornel Medical Center
Gary l. Kreps, George Mason University
Patricia D. Mail, University of Washington
John Sciacca, Northern Arizona University

were selected to move from the Review Board (back cover) to the Editorial Board (front inside cover) . All the new promotions are a little higher on the editorial chain. The change will appear beginning with the Jan/Feb 2005 issue of the journal.

I applaud ALL reviewers for your hard work and dedication for reviewing is the most thankless service that professionals provide. Hope that all of you have a great and prosperous new year!

Here are some facts for 2004 through Dec 15.

  1. we received 277 manuscripts; 56 accepted
  2. we had a 20% acceptance; 80% rejection
  3. we have 285 reviewers for the journal
  4. reviewers averaged 19.1 days response time to disposition after receiving a manuscript
  5. 36 reviewers averaged greater than the 21-day deadline, the most egregious and repeat offenders were removed (n=14)
  6. 44 reviewers were not assigned manuscripts to review
  7. 168 reviewers averaged 21 days or less
  8. 37 reviewers averaged less than 10 days
  9. 17 reviewers averaged 1 day!

Again, thank you for all your assistance.

glover
editor

Elbert D Glover, PhD, FASHA, FAAHB, FRIPH
RCBHSC / WVUSoM
Professor & Chair
Department of Public and Community Health
College of Health and Human Performance University of Maryland
2387 HHP Building
College Park MD 20742
301-405-2467 Voice
301-314-9167 Fax
eglover1@umd.edu
Web site: www.apmresearch.com

 
Last Modified: March 7, 2009
Ideas and opinions expressed in the Journal do not necessarily reflect those of the editors or publisher.


American Journal of Health Behavior™ is a registered trademark of PNG Publications.