American
Academy of Health Behavior Abstracts - 2000 Meeting
Paul D.
Sarvela, PhD, FAAHB, Abstract Co-Chair, 2000; Mark J. Kittleson,
PhD, FAAHB, Abstract Co-Chair, 2000; Terri Mulkins Manning, EdD,
Conference Chair, 2000; Robert J. McDermott, PhD, FAAHB, Program
Chair, 2000
Quick
Locator:
| Grochowski
& Karraker |
Grochowski |
Stevens,
McMillan, Colwell, Smith |
| Tricker
& Connolly |
Litt |
Strezelczyk
& Dignan |
| McCarthy
& Burg |
Glover,
Whoolery, Hobbs, Cerullo, Sullivan & Glover |
Umstattd,
Hallam, Connally & McCullough |
| Okwumabua,
Wong & Wright |
Sigelman,
Bridges, Sorongon, Rinehart, Leach, Mack & Davies |
Fan,
Pentz, & Chou |
| Laflin
& Horowitz |
Moore,
Werch, Owen & Carlson |
McClure,
Pentz, Huang & Pentz |
| Burke |
Carlson,
Werch, Pappas & Chally |
Nagy
& Clark |
| Then
& Rankin |
Walters |
Rankin
& Then |
| Weiler
& Pealer |
Brandon,
Meade, Herzog, Webb, Nath & Irwin |
Hallam,
Williams, Saxon & Johnston |
| Penz,
Pent, Huang & McClure |
Karshin,
Koch & Vicary |
Marks
& Allegrante |
| Weissbecker,
Weinrich & Weinrich |
Thombs,
Olds & Tomasek |
Eaton,
Bailey, Forthofer & McDermott |
| Wells |
Botelho |
Petosa,
Yost, Everman & Grim |
| Thomlinson,
Stanley & Schaible |
Petosa
& McGaha |
Rees
& Thompson |
| Byrne,
Yoo & Shama |
Henry,
Minner, Vicary & Bechtel |
Wilson,
Pawlak & Bernard |
| Nagy
& Clark |
Colabianchi
& Borwaski |
Nagy,
Nagy & Watts |
| Salveson
& Messecar |
Boekeloo,
Howard & O'Connor |
Morrissey
& Kittleson |
| Borawski,
Lovegreen, Tung & Abbott |
Thompson
& Rees |
Gerardi
& Berndt |
| Hammal
& Petosa |
Howard |
Faucher
& Carter |
| Trudeau
& Cook |
Young,
Denny, Rausch & Spear |
Dunn
& Werch |
| Avila,
Marks & Allegrante |
|
|
Using
Storytelling to Construct Preferred Futures and Enhance Resiliency
in Families: Insights from a Participatory, Dual-vision Methodology
Janet
R. Grochowski, Meg Wilkes Karraker
Purpose
To
explore the impact of a promising Delphi, anticipatory, story-based
strategy that engaged participants to not only describe their preferred
futures but what actions they were willing to take to reach these
preferred futures. The primary purpose was to explore what, if any,
impact this strategy had on participants" "sense of future."
Sense of future has been identified throughout resiliency literature
as a fundamental attribute of resiliency.
Framework
We
apply one author's concept, "strategic living communities"
(SLO), Antonovsky's salutogenic model, Benard's resiliency attributes,
and McCubbin's characteristics of resiliency families to the lived
experiences of single mothers. Our paper supports the views that
resilient families are proactively deconstructed and reconstructed
as their members negotiates the challenges and changes of living.
We have heard the stories of 17 single mothers who have completed
at least some college.
Overview
Authentic
research involving these women's lives and their dynamic communities
demands innovative methodological strategies in which the voices
of the women are at the center. Our dual-vision research model emphasizes
an exploratory, constructivistic approach with participants"
personalized phenomenology as the core. Implicit in our research
is a newer paradigm, a particularly feminist ethic: the research
process affects and is affected by those who participate.
Conclusions
In
the course of telling their stories about their preferred futures,
these single mothers are in fact constructing those futures. Other
findings and conclusions reveal that participants are willing to
take action today in order to meet their preferred futures, and
that exposure to this strategy positively impacted their views of
resiliency, health choices, and futures.
Top
Creating
Compelling Health Futures: Impacts of a Promising Story-Based Strategy
on Adolescents' Personal Health Projections
Janet
R. Grochowski
Purpose
This
exploratory, qualitative case study examined the impacts of an anticipatory,
self-directed, story-based learning strategy on adolescents' personal
health projections. This exploratory case study served as an examination
of the attributes of resiliency in the context of self-constructed
positive health futures.
Framework
Using
a constructivist research approach, thirteen seventeen year-old
participants constructed personal health projections including formative
and summative evaluations of their learning strategy experiences.
Overview
Participants'
personalized phenomenology was a focus of this case study. The content
analysis was carried out on each participant's personal health projections
(thirteen StoryLines exercises). Observable differences between
pre-case study, transitional, and post-case study were complied
with their associated analyses. Additional data sources included:
the participants' weekly journals; a post evaluation of the learning
strategy; a one-year evaluation; a fourteenth personal health projection
completed after one year; and the investigator's journal and observations.
The findings supported the use of this strategy in positively impacting
adolescents' personal health projections.
Conclusions
Eight
conclusions and numerous implications emerged for resiliency enhancement;
health education curriculum and pedagogy; and related roles for
health professionals, health educator preparation, families, communities,
and the individual client. The conclusions: StoryLines revealed
a positive impact on adolescents' personal health projections, participants
indicated that they enjoyed the use of StoryLines as a learning
strategy, participants demonstrated an ability to think in multiple
time-focused frames, exposure and practice appeared to assist participants
in challenging time-focused exercises, participants' attitudes toward
StoryLines played an interactive role in that it impacted their
confidence to think about their preferred health futures. Likewise,
practice in creating their preferred health futures appeared to
enhance their attitude toward futuring, participants stated that
StoryLines helped them to think about their preferred futures and
plan for them, participants indicated that they enjoyed futuring
and question why it is not used throughout health education.
Qualitative
Analysis of Co-morbid Behaviors Among Youth Taking Mandatory Smoking
Education Classes
Stacey
Stevens, Catherine McMillan, Brian Colwell, Dennis Smith
Purpose
To
analyze drawings and other writing on student workbooks utilized
in the Texas Adolescent Tobacco Use Awareness and Cessation Program.
The nature of these drawings and writings lends support to anecdotal
information that many participants in the program suffer from multiple
co-morbid behaviors that increase their risk of illness, injury
or premature mortality.
Methods
982
workbooks for a six-month period were sampled and examined. All
drawings and writings that were not part of class activities were
categorized. 73 "items" were included in this study, although
some words, phrases and/or drawings frequently appeared more than
once.
Results
In
preliminary analysis, the "items" were classified into
the following areas by topic referenced: alcohol use, drug use,
depression/fatalism/hopelessness, gang-related, violence/anarchy,
addiction, music, and other antisocial behaviors. 16 books could
be included into multiple categories.
Conclusions
Facilitators
of the ATCP work with adolescents who have a multitude of issues
beyond tobacco use. They should have high sensitivity to individuals
who may be experiencing significant mental health and/or antisocial
problems in order to ensure their referral into early intervention
programs as well as to assist their understanding of adolescents
with issues beyond tobacco use. Curriculum implications may include
the inclusion of activities that include more drawing/writing activities
for adolescents who express themselves in this manner, creation
of a more streamlined referral process to appropriate services,
and incorporating the input of other mental health professionals
to assist with program development and curriculum enhancement.
Top
Drugs
and The College Athlete: An Analysis of Athlete's at Risk
Ray
Tricker, D. Connolly
Purpose
To
examine the relative importance of selected attitudinal variables
that could be used to describe a profile of collegiate athletes
who were at risk for using anabolic steroids, human growth hormone,
amphetamines, cocaine and marijuana.
Methods
The
King Drugs in Sport Questionnaire was used to gather information
from 563 collegiate student athletes who were enrolled in two NCAA
Division One institutions. A subgroup of 120 student athletes were
selected from this pool based upon their responses to a list of
attitudinal scenarios that related to subjective norms, attitude
and perceived control (Ajzen and Fishbein). A descriptive profile
of at-risk student athletes was established from these data.
Results
The
results of the study indicated that 32% of the student athletes
had used marijuana during their lifetime and 19% reported that they
had used marijuana during the previous 6 months. Five percent had
used amphetamines during their lifetime and 1% during the past 6
months. Eight percent reported using anabolic steroids during their
lifetime. Thirty three percent reported that they would use anabolic
steroids if they could find ways of not testing positive. Fear of
discovery, loss of scholarship were described as major deterrents
for not using anabolic steroids. One hundred and seventy five student
athletes reported that they used marijuana to cope with the pressures
of sport, and 12% reported that they would use anabolic steroids
if these drugs would guarantee success in sport.
Conclusions
Subjective
norms and the perceptions that student athletes have of others'
use of drugs are an important influence on their decision to use
or not use. Therefore, it is important to develop strong networks
of support within athletic department that help to buffer external
influences and support strong positive internally motivated decision
making. Drug testing and athletic department policies should be
supplemented by regular opportunities for student athletes to meet
and examine their responsibilities in athletics and academics. education
should provide opportunities for student athletes to apply their
knowledge and ideas in challenging social situations and social
settings; for example, by making presentations in public schools
in front of their peers. The needs of student athletes in revenue
producing sports that emphasize strength and size may be different
from individuals who compete in nonrevenue sports.
Social
Learning Variables as Predictors of Exercise Initiation and Maintenance
in Older Women
Mark
D. Litt
Purpose
A
number of studies have documented the health benefits of exercise
in older women, including prevention of bone loss, enhancement of
postural mobility, and increased strength. Poor adherence to exercise
programs, however, limits the effectiveness of exercise programs.
Social learning theory predicts that adherence to a program will
be dependent on certain variables, including readiness or motivation
to exercise, confidence in ability (self-efficacy), and social support
for exercising. The purpose of the present study was to determine
whether social learning variables would predict continued adherence
to exercise in a group of elderly women at risk for osteoporosis.
Methods
Subjects
were 189 women ranging in age from 60 to 78 years, recruited from
the community, and prescribed exercise three times per week, plus
daily walking, for the purpose of examining the effects of continued
exercise on bone loss. Participants were administered questionnaires
at 3-month intervals for 36 months.
Results
Data
from the first 12 months indicated that initial exercise adherence
(exercise at 3 months) was predicted by readiness for exercise,
general social support and social support that was specific for
exercise (R2=.48). Continued exercise at 12 months, however,
was predicted only by continued exercise-specific social support
(R2=.18).
Conclusions
It
was concluded that those most likely to initiate behavior change
are those high in readiness and in social resources, but that the
process of maintaining exercise in this population is best accounted
for by exercise-specific support. Exercise programs that incorporate
continued support for exercise from friends and family may yield
better long-term adherence rates.
Top
Adherence
to Recommendations for Screening Mammography and Follow-up by Race
and Ethnicity
Jadwiga
(Jodi) Strzelczyk, Mark Dignan
Purpose
To
explain differences in screening behaviors and in levels of adherence
to follow-up recommendations among six racial/ethnic groups of women
from the Colorado Mammography Advocacy Project (CMAP) database for
the 1990-1997 period.
Methods
Data
from the records of 167,232 women included sociodemographic factors:
race/ethnicity (82.8% White, 3.4% African American, 11% Hispanic,
1.6% Asian, 0.6% Native American, and 0.6% "Other"), age,
education, health insurance, and family history of breast cancer
(FHBC). Clinical outcome data, stratified by the ACR mammography
conclusion codes, were utilized in the evaluation of adherence to
recommended follow-up for abnormal mammograms.
Results
Comparing
1990 and 1997, there was a ten-fold growth in the number of women
who had their first screening mammogram. Changes did not occur uniformly.
The largest participation increases were observed for Hispanic women
(5.5% to 34%), women aged 40-49 (34.9% to 40.5%), and women with
postgraduate education (6.4% to 9.9%). Decreases occurred for White
women (90% to 60%) and women with FHBC (15.8% to 10.7%). Overall,
80.7% of women adhered to recommended follow-up within 12 months;
only 75.4% of those with abnormal mammograms did. Significant differences
in adherence were observed between and within groups. Asian and
Native American, younger women, those less educated, without FHBC,
and those without health insurance were less likely to be adherent.
Conclusions
The
quantitative analyses reported here indicate that culture, age,
education, insurance, and FHBC interact with mammogram results to
influence the probability of adherence to recommended follow-up.
Learning
From Our Mistakes: Designing Behavioral Research Protocols in Academic
Family Practice Settings
Jennifer
R. McCarthy, Mary Ann Burg
Purpose
The
purpose of this presentation is to provide the community of health
behavior researchers with a descriptive assessment and analysis
of some of the barriers we faced in attempting to do behavioral
health research in an academic family practice setting. In order
to illustrate our points, we use the example of one research protocol
we launched but eventually abandoned when the obstacles to conducting
the protocol mounted beyond an acceptable cost-benefit ratio.
Methods
The
research protocol we use as an example to illustrate barriers to
behavioral health research involved the testing of an audiotape
intervention to enhance patient adherence to medical advice about
hypertension management. The original protocol included a two-group
time series design with random assignment of hypertensive patients
to a control and experimental group. The experimental group was
to get a take-home audiotape of their physician's discussion with
them of self-care approaches to improving their hypertension management.
Baseline chart data was to be collected for patients in both groups,
and patients were to be surveyed at three-month intervals over the
period of a year to collect data on patient adherence to hypertension
behavioral management guidelines.
Results
In
our attempt to implement the research protocol in our academic family
practice clinic we faced a series of unanticipated obstacles to
conducting the research as originally planned. These obstacles included:
1) technical problems with the clinic patient database that interfered
with random assignment into control and experimental groups; 2)
technical difficulties in tracking clinic patients for study recruitment;
3) local and non-local reasons for patient resistance to study recruitment;
4) research vs. usual clinic work-flow conflicts; 5) external validity
limitations. Finally, we will discuss how to "know when to
fish and cut bait", ie, determining when the obstacles to completing
a research project have mounted beyond an acceptable cost-benefit
ratio.
Conclusions
Anyone
who attempts to do serious behavioral health research is challenged
with the problem that sophisticated research design is not always
"doable" in the real life context of the primary care
clinic. It is better to anticipate potential barriers in designing
behavioral research protocols than to proceed with sophisticated
research designs that are not adaptable to real-life clinical practice
situations. We hope using our own mistakes as an example will help
other behavioral health researchers to design realistic protocols
that avoid some of the obstacles we faced in completing our research
program.
Top
Efficacy
of Bupropion SR for Smokeless Tobacco Cessation
Elbert
D. Glover, Judith Whoolery, Gerald Hobbs, Connie L. Cerullo, C.
Rolly Sullivan, Penny N. Glover
Purpose
To
determine the potential efficacy of bupropion SR for smokeless tobacco
cessation when used in combination with brief counseling.
Methods
The
study was a double blind, placebo-controlled trial that consisted
of a 7-week treatment with follow-up out to 3 months. After applying
specific inclusion and exclusion criteria, 70 Ss were allowed into
the trial and randomly assigned to a treatment of either bupropion
SR or placebo to a treatment ration of 1:1 (35 Ss per group).
Results
The
only efficacy results available at the time of abstract submission
are end of treatment (7 weeks) data which showed a success rate
of 52% for active and 26% for placebo for a Fisher's Exact Test
2-Tail of 0.0486 with an odds ratio of 2.0. Efficacy data at 3 months
and data comparing nicotine craving and severity of withdrawal from
smokeless tobacco will also be presented.
Conclusion
From
preliminary indications, bupropion SR appears to assist with stopping
smokeless tobacco use.
The
Use of Self-Regulation Skills, Exercise Self-Efficacy and Exercise
Outcome-Expectancies of Employed Adults
Renee
Umstattd, Jeffrey S. Hallam, Dale Connally, Melinda McCullough
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to examine the level exercise self-efficacy,
exercise self-regulation, and outcome-expectancy values for exercise
at each stage of exercise behavior as defined by the Transtheoretical
Model.
Methods
An
exercise stage-of-change instrument was sent to all employees (N=2,200)
of two worksites. Employees that returned the stage of change instrument
were asked to complete a questionnaire that measures exercise self-efficacy,
exercise self-regulation, outcome-expectancy value, stages-of-exercise,
current exercise behavior, and demographic information. All instruments
had established reliability and validity.
Results
The
results do not show any significant differences (p>.05) between
selected stage comparisons on the use of the social cognitive theory
variables. The exercise stages of change data were compared with
exercise behavior data and 17% of the subjects' behavior did not
match their reported stage.
Conclusions
Since
exercise stage determination is based on current exercise behavior,
these data indicate that the exercise stage of change instrument
may not be valid. Comparisons between regular exercisers and non-regular
exercisers on the three social cognitive theory variables were statistically
significant (p=.0001). Regular exercisers had significantly higher
levels of self-efficacy, self-regulation, and outcome-expectancy
value (p=.0001). Future research should examine these variables
across the continuum of exercise. Furthermore, the validity of the
exercise stage of change model should be examined.
Top
Depressive
Symptoms and Decision Making Patterns Among Low-income African American
Youth
Jebose
O. Okwumabua, S. P. Wong, Tamala D. Wright
Purpose
The
present study examined the presence of depressive symptoms among
low-income, inner-city African American youth in relation to their
decision-making and decision coping patterns.
Methods
Participants
comprised a sample of 270 African American male (n=113) and female
(n=144) students in sixth through tenth grades drawn from two public
schools in West Tennessee. The students ranged in age from 12 to
17 years. All participants were from low socioeconomic inner-city
neighborhoods. The Children's Depression Inventory (CDI) was used
to assess self-reported depressive symptomatology among participants.
A score of 19 or higher suggests the presence of depressive symptoms.
The Flinders Adolescent Decision Making Questionnaire (FADMQ) was
used to assess participants' decision-making patterns. The instrument
consists of decision self-esteem, Vigilance; Hypervigilance; Defensive
Avoidance; and Complacency. A high score on vigilance and self-esteem
indicates good decision making and confidence in making sound decisions.
The maximum possible score is 18. Analyses of variance, t-test,
and Chi-square statistical procedures were performed on data to
compare the identified variables.
Results
Of
the 257 participants who responded to CDI, approximately nine percent
(n=24) screened positive for the presence of depressive symptoms.
The older age group (16-17 years) scored slightly higher in reporting
of depressive symptoms than the younger age group (12-13 years).
There were significant differences among age groups on decision
coping patterns. The 12-13 year age group reported the lowest mean
score for complacency and avoidance decision coping styles when
compared to the two older age groups (14-15 and 16-17 years). The
group screenings positive for depressive symptoms were more likely
to report low scores for both decision self-esteem and vigilance
decision coping style. There were no significant gender differences
in the reporting of depressive symptoms and in the mean scores for
decision self-esteem and decision-coping styles.
Conclusions
Depression
is associated with maladaptive decision coping patterns. Perhaps
increasing competence in decision making may have beneficial effects
on overall mood and depressive symptoms among children and youth.
The authors will discuss the implications of this study for health
behavior research and interventions with children and youth.
Age
Differences in Children's Theories about Mechanisms of Drug Action
Carol
K. Sigelman, Lisa J. Bridges, Alberto G. Sorongon, Cheryl Rinehart,
Diane Leach, Keisha L. Mack, Elizabeth Davies
Purpose
Given
a lack of research on children's understandings of psychoactive
drugs, we used an intuitive theories approach to characterize age
differences in children's explanations of the mechanisms through
which alcohol and cocaine affect behavior.
Methods
Individual
interviews were conducted with 217 children ages 6 to 12 (one half
white, one-third African-American, the rest other). Parallel scores
reflecting mastery of propositions contained in a scientifically-correct
theory of drug action were formed from open-ended and corresponding
closed-ended responses. Common misconceptions were also examined.
Results
Analysis
of theory mastery scores based on open-ended responses suggested
that children generally do not know much. In contrast, closed-ended
questions revealed more knowledge overall. On both open- and closed-ended
items, first and second graders typically displayed less theoretical
knowledge than older children did. Gender and racial/ethnic differences
were minimal.
Conclusions
The
study illustrates an approach to characterizing children's intuitive
understandings of drug action (and other health phenomena), highlights
the implications of methodological choices for substantive findings,
suggests that even young elementary-school children have reasonable
intuitions about how the behavioral effects of drugs come about,
and offers empirical data on age-related differences in understanding
that can guide the design of drug education programs.
Influences
of Family and Peer on Drug Use Propensity in Childhood
Amy
Z. Fan, Mary Ann Pentz, Chih-Ping Chou
Purpose
To
explore the influence of family involvement, family supervision,
social competence with peers, support seeking, and parent and peer
drug use on drug use propensity in middle childhood.
Methods
Data
were obtained from a longitudinal, school-based drug abuse prevention
trial in Indianapolis. Participants were 1639 4th graders collected
by classroom from 48 elementary schools. We explored two kinds of
possible effect family and peer cohesion factors might take on child
drug use propensity, ie, moderating effects and/or mediating effects.
Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was conducted using EQS version
5.7.
Results
The
mediational analysis demonstrated little evidence that family involvement,
social competence with peers, and support-seeking are significant
mediators between the known risk factors (poor family supervision,
parental and peer drug use) and drug use propensity. The moderation
analysis indicated that low peer support-seeking skills exacerbates
the adverse effects of peer drug use on child drug use propensity;
low social competence with peers aggravates the unfavorable effects
of poor family supervision and parental drug use.
Conclusions
The
findings suggest that parental/family bonding and social competence
with peers may protect against drug use propensity during middle
childhood.
Top
Research
Publication and Access: A Guide to Indexes and Health Education
Journals
Molly
T. Laflin, Stephen M. Horowitz
Purpose
The
purpose of the project was to facilitate the development and dissemination
of the body of knowledge in the field of health education (HE).
A practical instrument was developed to assist health education
researchers in pairing their manuscript submissions with the most
appropriate journals. Furthermore, the top indexes in health education
literature were examined for the purpose of assisting scholars in
maximizing their literature searches and increasing the accessibility
of their research.
Methods
The
Delphi method was used to obtain information from HE scholars to
determine 1) primary content areas in HE, 2) preeminent journals,
and 3) information regarding these journals. Using this information,
a frequency count was performed to identify the type and number
of indexes covering the identified HE journals.
Results
Nine
broad journal categories and 86 journals pertaining to HE were selected.
The following was obtained for each journal: circulation, rejection
rate, indexes where cited, number of issues, pages per issue, article
length, articles per issue, time between submission and notification,
time between acceptance and publication, peer review policy, style,
CEUs, and journal descriptions. The indexes Current Contents, PsychINFO,
Research Alert, SSCI, and ERIC provided the best coverage of HE
journals. Index coverage varied by content areas.
Conclusions
Understanding
the strengths and weaknesses of journals and indexes can help health
educators more effectively search the literature, and can assist
researchers in making appropriate manuscript submission decisions.
Matching manuscripts to appropriate journals, and addressing issues
related to indexing, can facilitate the dissemination of quality
research in HE.
Factors
Associated with Heavy Drinking among First Year University Students
Michele
J. Moore, Chudley E. Werch, Deborah M. Owen, Joan M. Carlson
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to examine risk and protective factors
associated with stage of binge drinking initiation and binge drinking
among first year residential university students. This research
is part of a larger study of a binge drinking prevention intervention.
The influence of various risk and protective factors on binge drinking
is important to take into consideration for planning effective prevention
programs.
Methods
At
the beginning of fall semester 1998, baseline data were collected
from a cohort of first year residential students (n=634). At the
close of spring semester 1999, post-test data were collected (n=522).
The 68-item survey measured demographics, alcohol use, stage of
binge drinking initiation, and alcohol risk and protective factors.
Internal reliability coefficients ranged from .71 to .91. Preliminary
analyses were conducted measuring the effects of risk and protective
factors on post-test binge drinking behavior and stage of initiating
binge drinking.
Results
Data
indicate that having positive expectations regarding heavy alcohol
use; being influenced by others to drink heavily; perceiving that
friends drink heavily and approve of heavy drinking; perceiving
that parents approve of drinking heavily; and having more opportunities
to drink heavily are significantly (p<.05) associated with binge
drinking and progression in the stages of initiating binge drinking.
Lower levels of perceived susceptibility and severity of binge drinking;
motivation and use of self-control methods to avoid binge drinking;
and perceived benefits of avoiding binge drinking were also significantly
(p<.05) associated with binge drinking and progression in the
stages of initiating binge drinking.
Conclusions
Multiple
risk and protective factors are linked to stage of initiating binge
drinking and binge drinking behavior. Additional multivariate analyses
will be conducted on the data and implications for alcohol interventions
will be discussed.
Top
Effects
of a Multi-Component Policy Intervention On Adolescent Smoking Susceptibility
Maykami
L. McClure, Mary Ann Pentz, Terry Huang, Clyde A. Pentz
Purpose
The
Tobacco Program and Policy Trial (TOPP) was designed as a way for
schools to increase the potential of school policy to reduce adolescent
tobacco use. It was hypothesized that a school-based tobacco intervention
program designed to support and enhance school no-smoking policies
would lower California adolescent susceptibility to smoking (ie,
intentions to smoke).
Methods
Participants
were ethnically diverse students (N=2,053) in 7th grade from middle
schools (N=19) in Orange County, California. Schools were randomly
assigned to one of two experimental groups: a multi-component policy
intervention condition (three-session tobacco-policy curriculum
for students, school tobacco-policy review workshop, school tobacco-policy
awareness training for parents and the parent teacher organization,
and school tobacco-policy review interviews with principals) (n=10),
or a control (policy as usual) condition (n=9). The intervention
involved a three-session curriculum focusing on school tobacco policy
awareness and support, and tobacco influences, consequences, and
social norms. Students were asked to complete a questionnaire on
cigarette-use, policy awareness, policy support, and risks of tobacco
use at baseline, 6-month, and 1-year follow-up.
Results
Regression
analysis was used to obtain adjusted estimates of odds ratios for
smoking susceptibility. Participants in the program group were 1.6
times as likely than those in the control group to indicate they
will definitely not smoke a cigarette in the next few months (OR=1.6,
95% CI=1.2, 2.0).
Conclusions
Based
on this study, a curriculum-based intervention focusing on increasing
policy awareness may also be effective in changing adolescent smoking
susceptibility status.
Peer
Approval and Peer Pressure: Factors Influencing Smoking Intentions
Adam
Burke
Purpose
The
relationship between peers and smoking is widely observed, but not
well understood. To explore this dynamic, this study examined peer
influences contributing to the intentions of fifth graders to smoke
cigarettes in one year. Of key interest was the distinction between
peer approval of smoking and peer pressure to smoke.
Methods
A
sample of 392 fifth grade students was surveyed regarding tobacco
use and attitudes using an anonymous 42-item questionnaire. As the
main focus was on how peer influences contribute to smoking intention,
the dependent variable chosen was behavioral intention to smoke
in one year. Behavioral intention has been shown to be a useful
predictor of future action.
Results
In
the entire sample (n=392) the majority of students had never tried
tobacco (82%, n=320) and had no friends that smoked (81%, n=318).
Multiple regression to predict current smoking was run on this whole
sample. Peer smoking was found to be the best single predictor of
current tobacco use. Multiple regression was then performed on the
subsample of students with no smoking experience and no siblings
or best friends who smoked (n=259) to determine the best predictors
of behavioral intention to smoke in one year. The best predictor
of intention to smoke was perceived peer approval. The contribution
of perceived peer pressure was not significant.
Conclusions
These
findings support the importance of peer influence. They also suggest
that peer influences to smoke cigarettes may be experienced positively
(peer approval) rather than negatively (peer pressure). This suggests
the need for earlier interventions, with appropriate information
on peer attitudes and behaviors.
Top
Binge
Drinking Initiation and Problems among Incoming Residential College
Students
Joan
M Carlson, Chudley E. Werch, Deborah M. Pappas, Pamela S. Chally
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to examine the prevalence of binge drinking
initiation and problems among incoming residential first-year college
students.
Methods
Eighty-eight
percent (n=634) of freshmen residential students attending a southern
university completed a standardized questionnaire within the first
six weeks of the fall semester of 1998. The questionnaire displayed
internal consistency (reliability) alpha coefficients ranging from
.58 to .91, with only two measures under .70.
Results
Stages
of binge drinking initiation results reveal 4% of students maintaining
binge drinking for longer than 6 months, 24% preparing/initiating
binge drinking, 3% thinking of drinking heavily in the near future,
and 69% not thinking of drinking heavily. Results also showed that
nearly half (49%) of incoming freshmen residential students had
occasionally gotten drunk, and almost half (47%) had not received
any alcohol or drug education during the past year. Problems associated
with binge drinking included 33% experiencing a hangover within
the past three months, 22% doing something they regretted, and 13%
having unplanned sex after drinking. Problems associated with others'
binge drinking included 39% of students taking care of friends who
drank too much, 27% had sleep/study interrupted, and 13% reported
experiencing unwanted sexual advances.
Conclusions
Binge
drinking initiation and problems associated with heavy alcohol use
are fairly common even among students on campus for only a short
period. Future research exploring drinking problems of incoming
residential freshmen college students and the prevention of binge
drinking will be discussed.
Using
Theoretical Constructs in the Conceptualization and Development
of a Curriculum
Stephen
Nagy, Leslie F. Clark
Purpose
To
share the methodology of curricular design. A developmental, strength-based
curriculum to reduce at-risk behaviors for students in grades 6,
7, and 8 utilized the Theory of Possible Selves and Health Education
Theory to provide a framework for curriculum development as part
of an intervention to address risky behaviors among young adolescents.
Framework
The
theoretical frameworks utilized in this project included the Theory
of Possible Selves, Health Education Theory and Social Learning
Theory. Constructs within the Theory of Possible Selves included
might become (expanding a student's perception of their life possibilities),
hope to become (identifying with future possibilities and setting
some goals), and afraid of becoming (recognizing environmental deterrents
and not identifying with negative role models). The two main constructs
from Health Education Theory included wellness (growth activities
to enhance physical, social and intellectual well-being) and risk
reduction (activities designed to orient the student toward safety
issues regarding behavior). The final theoretical contribution was
made using Social Learning Theory and a variety of constructs were
utilized in preparing the individual learning activities.
Overview
The
methodology utilized to develop the Future Selves Curriculum incorporated
a three stage developmental process. Stage one involved the development
of the main themes of the curricula for each grade level as well
as themes for the four units within each grade level. This activity
utilized a strength-based philosophy, centering largely on identifying
and building on student's own assets. The second stage determined
the emphasis of the theoretical constructs within the curricula.
This incorporated a blending of constructs from the Theory of Possible
Selves coupled with one of the two Health Education constructs.
An outcome of this process was a framework with an emphasis on the
desired theoretical constructs. Individual lesson plans were developed
in the third stage with full consideration given to attending to
main themes, unit themes, and theoretical constructs. Activities
in the individual lesson plans were based on Social Learning Theory.
A review of the methodology will incorporate a detailed description
of the various processes utilized within each stage.
Conclusions
The
development of an intervention should be theoretical driven and
theory should be applied in the conceptualization of curriculum
materials, unit development and individual lessons. It is important
to consider how theoretical constructs are blended together to address
the priorities of the project and remain true to the theoretical
constructs that were utilized to conceptualize the intervention.
This presentation outlines the methodology utilized in the Picken's
County Family Life Program and may serve to assist others in application
of theory in the design of curriculum.
Top
Tobacco
Issues in a Regional Health Authority: The Public's Opinion
Karen
L. Then, James A. Rankin
Purpose
The
Calgary Tobacco Reduction Action Coalition (CTRAC) is a multidisciplinary
coalition. The main goal of CTRAC is to improve the health of individuals,
families, and communities by preventing and reducing tobacco use
through community based initiatives. The purpose of this study (commissioned
by CTRAC) was to survey the public's opinion regarding tobacco usage,
associated health risks and enactment and enforcement of healthy
public policy.
Methods
A
telephone survey conducted over a three month period in Calgary
(population approximately 800,000), Canada, using a random digit
dialing procedure. A total of 626 respondents (52% female, 48% male)
completed the questionnaire for an overall response rate of 68%.
The
survey was subdivided into eight sections with 34 major items. There
were 5 open-ended questions. The survey took a maximum of 20 minutes
to complete.
Results
Results
of the public consultation survey revealed that 45% never smoked,
27% are current smokers, and 28% were past smokers, with 53% of
respondents having completed college/technical school or university.
The major findings indicate:
-
88% support initiatives restricting tobacco use, particularly in
areas where children may be exposed - 33% would frequent restaurants
or cafés more frequently if they were 100% smoke-free - over 90%
believe that smoking is associated with lung cancer and heart disease.
Just over 42% believe that smoking is associated with ear problems
in children and SIDS - 66% believe that tobacco should not be sold
in pharmacies
Conclusions
The
results indicate that there is strong support among the public for
health initiatives that would restrict tobacco use. There were fairly
high rates of support for certain significant items, even among
smokers. The implications for healthy public policy and health education
are discussed.
Experiential
Food Education: Cooking with Kids
Lynn
M. Walters
Purpose
The
purpose of the intervention is to enable elementary school children
to make sound nutritional choices by learning to accept a wide variety
of healthy foods.
Framework
The
connection between diet and chronic disease has been well documented.
Cooking with Kids is based on an ecological model, which suggests
that behavior is influenced by intrapersonal, social, cultural,
and physical environmental variables and the interactions of these
variables. Cooking with Kids was inspired by the award-winning food
acceptance research of Dr. Antonia Demas in Trumansburg, NY.
Overview
Cooking
with Kids began in 1995, using interdisciplinary, hands-on methods
to increase acceptance of nutritious foods, modeling healthy, culturally
diverse food choices in elementary school classrooms and in school
cafeterias. The program currently operates in six Santa Fe Public
Schools; a satellite recently began in Cimarron, NM. Original curriculum
provides a format for each class, integrating language arts, science,
math, social studies, music and art. During the 1999-2000 school
year, sixteen hundred students, grades K through 6, participated
in more than seven hundred hands-on food education classes. Examples
include Green and White Fettuccine with Tomato Basil Sauce, Llapingachos,
Chinese American Fried Rice, and Black Bean Tamales with Red Chile.
Cooking with Kids received a Quality of Education Award by the New
Mexico Research and Study Council.
Conclusions
Conclusions
support the hypothesis that student participation in food preparation
increases acceptance of new foods. Cooking with Kids is evaluated
by classroom teachers, food educators, and students. One girl commented,
after preparing and tasting Greek Pastitsio, "There is joy
in my mouth now."
Top
A
Smoke Free Policy in a Regional Health Authority: The Staff's
Opinion
James
A. Rankin, Karen L. Then
Purpose
In
January 1999 the Calgary Regional Health Authority (CRHA) board
approved a Tobacco Reduction policy in principle but needed more
data. The opinion of staff members was sought in order to determine
how the policy should be implemented. The purpose of the study was
to obtain the opinions of CRHA staff regarding current smoking practices
and the proposed policy changes.
Methods
The
method included a self-administered questionnaire and focus group
discussions. A total of 1860 questionnaires were completed and three
focus groups were conducted.
Results
Results
of the staff survey revealed that 59% never smoked, 10% are current
smokers, and 31% were past smokers. The results of the study indicate:
-
The largest percentage of current smokers work in either care centers
or nursing homes
-
"Very important" reasons for a smoke-free policy included:
protecting patients and employees from second-hand smoke (78%),
sending a health message to the community (71%)
-
Education on how to cope or quit smoking should be provided (75%)
-
Inform public of policy change by multimedia campaign
-
Set target dates and phase in implementation plan
-
64% stated that there should be exceptions to the policy (eg, long-term
care, palliative care and psychiatry)
Conclusion
There
was strong support for the policy change among the CRHA staff, however
it is vitally important that the CRHA is seen to be empathic toward
smokers and that the policy represents a health initiative. The
smoke-free policy should be portrayed as the first step towards
a Total Health Management approach to CRHA staff. The implications
for healthy public policy and health education are discussed.
Adolescent
Health Concerns: An Exploratory Qualitative Analysis
Robert
M. Weiler, Lisa N. Pealer
Purpose
Inspecting
the health concerns of adolescents can help determine the congruence
between health problems, as confirmed by epidemiologic data, and
issues about which they are concerned. Such knowledge is useful
when planning health promotion programs. However, adolescent health
concerns are usually assessed using questionnaires that ask adolescents
to identify from a preconstructed list, those issues that are concern
to them. This approach may introduce bias by accentuating concerns
that are inconsequential or concealing genuine concerns. This study
assessed the health concerns of adolescents by using an open-ended
self-administered question.
Methods
Data
were collected during Spring 1999 from 3,695 (N=6,780) students
in grades 9-12 attending eight high schools in two Florida school
districts using the Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) developed
by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The data were
collected as part of two independent needs assessment projects for
two school districts. In addition to completing the 86-item YRBS,
students were instructed to respond to an open-ended question, "The
greatest concern I have about my health is..." Responses were
post-coded using an existing instrument developed to assess the
health concerns of adolescents.
Results
Preparatory
results revealed that most students who responded to the question,
provided a genuine response. Yet, responses that had either an indifferent
or smart aleck tone were found. Most students reported only one
health concern. Individual responses are being arranged and ordered
into broad topic areas. For example, the response allergy, arthritis,
diabetes, colds, stomachs, and so on will comprise the "specified
disease experience" content area. Fifty-seven general health
concerns have been identified. Though analysis is not complete,
the most prevalent health concerns by rank and frequency are weight,
general appearance, staying healthy, and nutrition and diet.
Conclusions
Findings
reveal health issues adolescents are personally concerned about,
suggesting potential content areas that should be addressed in school
health curricula and other health education programs. They also
indicate items that should be added to instruments designed to assess
adolescent health concerns.
Top
Cost-Effective
Prevention of Smoking Relapse
Thomas
H. Brandon, Cathy D. Meade, Thaddeus A. Herzog, Monica S. Webb,
Vani Nath, Jennifer E. Irvin
Purpose
Tobacco
smoking cessation has the greatest impact on mortality of any health-related
behavior change. Unfortunately, the vast majority of ex-smokers
eventually relapse. The goal of this line of research is to develop
cost-effective minimal interventions for preventing smoking relapse
among self-quit ex-smokers.
Methods
An
initial study that surveyed ex-smokers found that the preferred
minimal interventions were a telephone hotline and a series of mailings.
We tested these interventions in a crossed 2x2 design. Subjects
were 446 ex-smokers who had quit for at least one week. The mailings
comprised a series of 8 Stay Quit booklets based on relapse-prevention
theory and research. Both interventions were offered over one year.
Results
At
the 12-month follow-up, we found that the hotline was ineffective.
However, the repeated mailings reduced relapse versus a control
condition in which subjects received only a single booklet. Among
recent quitters (<3 months of abstinence at baseline), the booklets
reduced relapse by approximately two-thirds (12% vs. 35%). A cost-effectiveness
analysis found that the cost of producing a year of abstinence was
$126in contrast to $2000 or more for typical cessation-focused
interventions.
Conclusions
Mailing
a series of relapse-prevention booklets proved to be an effective
and cost-effective means to maintain abstinence among recent quitters.
The main goal of an ongoing study is to determine the potent elements
of the mailing intervention: the relapse-prevention content of the
booklets versus the extended contact with subjects. This line of
research demonstrates how clinic-based interventions can be translated
into written formats that increase their accessibility and cost-effectiveness.
The
Use of the Transtheoretical Model Processes in College Student Exercise
Behavior
Jeffrey
S. Hallam, Danielle Williams, Terrill Saxon, Deborah Johnston
Purpose
The
United States Department of Health and Human Services (2010) specifically
identifies post-secondary institutions as settings where young adults
should be targeted for exercise promotion. The CDC (1999) reports
that even though college students have access to exercise facilities,
as well as physical activity classes, there is a decline in total
physical activity during college. This decline occurs even though
exercise promotion programs (EPP) are offered through coursework,
campus recreation, and wellness departments. One explanation for
this decline is the lack of theory-based EPPs at the college level.
The Transtheoretical Model (TTM) offers a framework to develop EPPs
that may increase the adoption and maintenance of college student
exercise behavior; yet, the use of the TTM processes by this population
is not known. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to describe
the use of the TTM processes in a college student population.
Methods
Seven
hundred ninety-four students enrolled in a general health class
served as the accessible sample. Questionnaires were distributed
to 708 students resulting in 699 useable questionnaires. The Processes
of Change questionnaire developed by Marcus (1992) was used to access
the use of the TTM Processes (Experiential and Behavioral processes).
The Stages of Change questionnaire developed by Marcus and Simkin
(1993) was used to determine exercise stage of change. Exercise
behavior was also measured using a seven-day recall instrument (Dishman
and Steinhardt, 1990). Each instrument has established validity
and reliability. MANOVA was used to examine differences in the ten
TTM processes across the five stages. Post hoc analysis (Tukey HSD)
was used to test difference between stages. Alpha level was set
at P=.05 (a priori).
Results
Fifty-nine
percent of participants were categorized in the Action and Maintenance
stages. By definition, 59% are regular exercisers - which is different
than national data that estimate 39% of college students are regular
exercisers. Furthermore, only 15 students were categorized in Precontemplation
stage. The MANOVA revealed significant differences for each process
across all levels of stage. Post hoc analysis revealed seven different
processes that were significant between adjacent stages. Three experiential
processes were not significantly different between adjacent stages.
There is a linear increase in all processes across stages except
for Environmental Reevaluation. Additional analysis revealed that
28% of the subjects; reported exercise behavior did not; match their
reported exercise stage of change.
Conclusions
In
developing stage-matched EPPs, health behavior specialists should
build on specific processes to help students progress to the next
stage. For this sample, targeted processes to help precontemplators
move to contemplators are consciousness raising, self-reevaluation,
counter-conditioning, and social liberation. To move contemplators
to preparers the targeted processes are counter-conditioning, reinforcement
management, and social liberation. To move preparers to action,
the targeted processes are consciousness raising, self-reevaluation,
counterconditioning and helping relationships, and to move those
subjects in action to maintenance, the targeted processes are consciousness
raising, counterconditioning, social liberation and stimulus control.
The experiential processes may play are more useful role in helping
students' progress to the next stage. Further research should examine
how the changes in the processes subsequently lead to changes in
exercise behavior. Furthermore, it is not known how the processes
change. Before researchers and practitioners' design staged-match
EPPs, they should consider this suggestion. The validity and reliability
of the exercise stages of change instrument should be examined.
These results show 28% of the sample were not categorized correctly,
as measured by the stages of change instrument. Everman (2000) conducted
a review of the exercise stage of change literature and found similar
results. Bandura (1997) argues there is no need to measure stage.
This issue needs further research to explain the utilization of
measuring stage of change and subsequently designing staged matched
intervention programs.
Top
Relationship
of School Tobacco Policy to Adolescent Tobacco Use
Clyde
A. Penz, Mary Ann Pentz, Terry Huang, Maykami McClure
Purpose
School
Policy related to tobacco and drug use has focused on "zero
tolerance" with a primary focus on punishment, specifically
expulsion or suspension. As part of Project TOPP (Tobacco Program
and Policy), this study was designed to evaluate the effects of
school policy on tobacco use in 19 middle schools in 3 school districts
in Southern California.
Methods
School
principals were interviewed and their tobacco policies were categorized
as either punitive (suspend), situational (where the principal determined
the schools action depending on the past history of the student),
and humanistic (where the principal's response was focused on trying
to help the student, including placing the student in a cessation
program). During principal interviews, surveys were also collected
on 2,434 students in the 7th grade. Questions included lifetime
and monthly tobacco use, awareness of school policy, and support
for school tobacco policy. Principal interviews and adolescent surveys
were repeated in the 8th grade.
Results
Longitudinal
data were analyzed with conditional regression analysis models,
using school and individual as the units of analysis, controlling
for baseline levels of principal interview variables and student
tobacco use and policy support variables. Results showed that changes
in policy emphasis toward more prevention and cessation support,
were related to lower tobacco use over time. Punishment emphasis
and change toward more punishment emphasis, had no effect on tobacco
use or policy variables.
Conclusions
Findings
suggest that even in a zero tolerance climate, there is room for
change in policy emphasis in schools, and that in emphasis on prevention
and cessation support are more effective than punishment.
Predictors
of Alcohol Consumption among College Students: An Examination of
Gender Differences
Christine
M. Karshin, Patricia B. Koch, Judith R. Vicary
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to examine whether gender differences
exist in relation to the predictive powers of positive alcohol expectancies
and perceived friends' use of alcohol on alcohol consumption among
college students. In addition, this study examined the degree to
which self-efficacy to control drinking mediates these effects.
Methods
The
data for this analysis were drawn from a sample of 369 undergraduate
students attending seven introductory health classes at a major
northeastern university. The subjects completed the College Health
and Academics Survey (CHAS), a 385-item questionnaire, during the
fall and spring semesters of the 1997-98 academic year.
Results
Results
indicate that both positive drinking expectancies (p<.01) and
perceived friends' use (p<.01) positively predict recent drinking
behavior. Positive drinking expectancies were also highly significant
predictors of self-efficacy to control drinking (p<.000). Self-efficacy
to control drinking was also shown to play an important and key
intervening role in the pattern of alcohol use among college students.
It
was also hypothesized that a gender difference would be evident
in the relationship between perceived friends' use and drinking
behavior as mediated by self-efficacy to control drinking. Males
were expected to place a greater amount of emphasis on their motivation
to comply with their reference group's perceived alcohol-related
behaviors. The results of this analysis confirm this hypothesis.
Conclusions
The
results of this study lend additional supporting evidence regarding
the trends and patterns of alcohol use among college students. The
information provided should be considered when planning and implementing
alcohol-related intervention programs that target college students.
Top
Body
Mass Indices in Disabling Hip Arthritis
Ray
Marks, John P. Allegrante
Purpose
To
determine whether individuals diagnosed as having disabling hip
joint arthritis across the lifespan would have body mass indices
(BMIs)indicating they were either overweight or obese.
Methods
The
BMIs of 425 males and females ranging in age from 26-92 years, and
requiring surgery for hip osteoarthritis, a potentially preventable
degenerative joint disease, were recorded by an independent nurse
specialist according to standard procedures. Being overweight was
defined as having a BMI of at least 25 kg/m2, whilst being obese
was defined as having a BMI of 30 kg/m2 or more as per CDC guidelines.
Results
Body
mass indices higher than age-associated norms were recorded for
at least 65% of all cases surveyed, regardless of age category studied.
At ages 30-39 years, 62.5% of 16 cases in this age category had
BMIs >25 with an average BMI of 28.80. Patients who had had previous
surgery and complications warranting reimplantation of new surgical
devices had BMIs on average in the obese range.
Conclusions
It
is possible that as with disabling knee arthritis, cumulative exposure
to excessive body weight during childhood and throughout adult life
may contribute to early and continuous degeneration of the hip joint(s)
and to a poorer outcome than one might anticipate from joint replacement
surgery. As advocated by the CDC and AF, interventions to obviate
poor nutritional practices and promote activity in early life, along
with weight-loss programs in adult life may be important in efforts
to reduce the disability and substantial morbidity of hip osteoarthritis.
Knowledge
of Risks Associated with Prostate Cancer (CaP) Screening and Treatment
Inka
Weissbecker, Sally P. Weinrich, Martin C. Weinrich
Purpose
To
contrast knowledge of risks between men who attended a free screening
and men who did not attend.
Methods
A
low-income zip code area in Louisville, KY, with a high CaP mortality
rate was chosen, and all men over 40 received a letter announcing
a free CaP screening. The men who attended the screening (n=25)
completed a questionnaire, and randomly selected men who chose not
to attend (n=17) were interviewed by telephone. The 42 men were
80% African American with a mean age of 52 years. The Knowledge
of Risks and Benefits Scale has eight items, a 5th grade reading
level and a reliability (theta) of 0.61 using factor analysis. A
three-item Risk Subscale measured knowledge of risks of incontinence,
impotence and the lack of agreement among experts about CaP screening.
Descriptive analyses and Mann-Whitney tests were performed.
Results
Surprisingly
there were no significant differences in the mean number of items
answered correctly between men who came for the screening (M=4.0)
and men who did not attend (M=3.76, p>.10). Similarly, there
were no significant differences on the Risk Subscale between the
two groups (p>.10). Only 19% of the men knew that experts disagree
over whether or not they should have a CaP checkup. In contrast,
most men knew about the risk of incontinence (57.1%) and the risk
of impotence (64.3%).
Conclusions
This
study highlights the need to inform men about the risks of CaP screening
and treatment in order to comply with CaP screening guidelines,
which emphasize informed decision-making.
Top
Seventh
to Twelfth Graders' Perceptions of College Student Drinking
Dennis
L. Thombs, R. Scott Olds, Jennifer Ray Tomasek
Purpose
To
examine relationships between perceptions of college student drinking
and substance use risk factors.
Methods
An
anonymous survey was administered to 2,017 Ohio public school students
in grades 7-12.
Results
Only
5% of the sample indicated that they had never heard about alcohol
use among college students. The sample perceived very high rates
of college student drinking at "typical campus parties,"
with the mean number of drinks consumed as 9-10. The distribution
of the student ratings had a pronounced positive skew. For example,
about 14% of the sample perceived that "20 or more drinks"
(the most extreme response option) were consumed by typical college
students at typical campus parties. A discriminant function analysis
showed that this segment of students was at high-risk for tobacco,
alcohol, and marijuana use, and were likely to perceive that substance
use was normative behavior among their current schoolmates.
Conclusions
By
seventh grade, judgments about alcohol use on campus appear to be
formed in a large majority of students. Frequently, these perceptions
of normative drinking behavior appear to grossly exaggerate the
extent of drinking on campus when compared to findings from national
studies on college student drinking. The presence of these erroneous
perceptions may be a marker for alcohol and drug problems in individual
youth. The findings suggest that social norm marketing campaigns
need directed at middle schools and high schools. The data also
challenge universities to incorporate alcohol misuse indicators
into their admissions criteria and to educate prospective students
about alcohol in their recruitment efforts.
Triangulation
of Methods for Evaluation of Complex Health Promotion Processes:
The Florida Prevention Research Center's Community-Based Prevention
Marketing Model
Danice
K. Eaton, Lauren J. Bailey, Melinda S. Forthofer, Robert J. McDermott
Purpose
To
present the methods used by the Florida Prevention Research Center
(FPRC) to evaluate the Community-Based Prevention Marketing (CBPM)
model implemented in the demonstration community of Sarasota County,
Florida.
Framework
The
CBPM model is a community-directed process for promoting social
change by applying marketing strategies and community organization
principles to the design, implementation, and evaluation of health
promotion and disease prevention programs. A central principal of
CBPM is community participation and control.
Overview
The
FPRC is employing a comprehensive evaluation to determine the utility
of the CBPM model to prevent alcohol and tobacco use by middle school
youth. The evaluation is three-pronged, including context, process
and impact measures.
Context
evaluation assesses events or activities occurring in the community
during the project that may influence project outcomes. Strategies
used in context evaluation include content analysis of media and
relevant local agency/coalition activities and local event logs.
Process
evaluation assesses the fidelity of the model's implementation.
Tools used in process evaluation include monitoring of training
and interviews with key informants.
Impact
evaluation relates the CBPM process to changes in the community's
ability to sustain the CBPM process beyond the initial demonstration
project period. Key outcome measures assess community capacity at
regular intervals.
Conclusions
Triangulation
of research methods will optimize the comprehensiveness and validity
of the CBPM model's evaluation. Improving the CBPM model enhances
its potential to address other populations and issues.
Top
Smoking
Cessation Benefits among Managed Care Health Plans
Marilyn
J. Wells
Purpose
Smoking
costs managed care health plans nearly $20 million in avoidable
medical and health care costs annually. Effective smoking cessation
treatments including, prescription and over-the-counter medications
and behavioral interventions, however, can significantly and positively
impact the financial burden of smoking on managed care. Therefore,
the purpose of this market research was to determine the extent,
to which health maintenance organizations (HMOs) routinely include
smoking cessation as a covered benefit. Key-decision makers on health
plan benefits, key decision-making steps in the benefit design process,
and key influential factors for determining covered benefits also
were investigated.
Methods
From
the population of all licensed HMOs in the United States (N=625),
a sample of convenience (n=35) was selected based on industry and
geographic representation. Data were collected through telephone
interviews of HMO management using a structured interview guide,
and verified through review of health plan documents and marketing
materials. Quantitative and qualitative methods were employed for
data analysis.
Results
Results
indicate that approximately 90% of health plans do not include smoking
cessation as a core plan benefit, even though nearly three-fourths
promote smoking cessation through value-added services. Concerns
over the cost-effectiveness, cost-benefit, and efficacy of smoking
cessation interventions, as well as lack of competitive-advantage
and standardized performance measures were reported as key barriers.
Conclusions
Recommendations
include educating health plan consumers, managed care decision makers,
and healthcare professionals on the financial impact of smoking
on managed care, smoking cessation guidelines and treatments, and
the beneficial outcomes (clinical, economic, and humanistic) of
smoking cessation benefits and services.
Developing
Motivational Practitioners: A Postmodern Approach
Rick
J. Botelho
Purpose
To
describe how practitioners can adopt a motivational role with patients
and use a method of continuing professional development (CPD) to
address health behavior change
Framework
The
concept of roles delineates how practitioners can behave differently
with patients. First, they need to learn how to change themselves
(second order change) before changing others (first order change).
Then, practitioners can use a six-step approach in how to adopt
a motivational role with patients. This mental map incorporated
12 motivational principles, theories and models in a coherent and
pragmatic manner for busy practitioners.
Overview
Practitioners
have been predominantly trained to adopt a "fix-it" role
in addressing unhealthy behaviors. Health information and advice
works with a minority of patients (5-20%). This role is dysfunctional
for resistant patients. Practitioners can learn how to adopt a motivational
role with resistant patients, before they learn how to develop motivational
skills. Self-directed, lifelong learning methods along with ongoing
training opportunities can help practitioners continually develop
their skills throughout their professional careers: from novices
to masters. Effective education can accelerate their professional
development as motivational practitioners.
Conclusions
CPD
can increase practitioner satisfaction and performance in helping
resistant patients change over time. They can work with patients
when proven interventions of limited effectiveness do not work.
A motivational approach can help them engage these patients in dialogues
over time. They can develop individualized interventions to meet
patients' changing needs over time. Effective interventions help
patients change their perceptions and values in ways that they motivate
themselves to change.
Top
A
Prospective Study of Social Cognitive Theory Determinants of Physical
Activity
Rick
A. Petosa, Jason Yost, Melinda Everman, Melissa Grim
Purpose
The
purpose of the study was to prospectively test selected Social Cognitive
Theory (SCT) variables in predicting free living physical activity
in college students. The study focused on the SCT variables of self-regulation,
self-efficacy, outcome expectancy value, and social support. These
variables were chosen as potentially modifiable in the context of
university exercise promotion programs.
Methods
The
sample consisted of 400 undergraduate students enrolled in an general
studies courses at a midwestern university. The subjects were tested
over a period of ten weeks. In weeks one and two, the variables
of self-efficacy, self-regulation, outcome expectancy value, social
support. In weeks three through ten seven-day recall of moderate
and vigorous exercise was collected. All instruments have established
reliability and validity.
Results
Only
10% of the sample met recommended levels of physical activity consistently
over a period of five weeks. Results revealed a mean of 1.5 days
per week (SD =1.4) for vigorous exercise. Multiple regression analysis
revealed that the SCT variables accounted for 30% of the variance
in total days of vigorous exercise. Significant variables were outcome-expectancy
value (p=.008) and self-efficacy (p=.02). Self-regulation and social
support were not significant (p>.05).
Conclusions
Almost
all studies of the determinants of free living physical activity
are done retrospectively. This prospective study revealed that college
students' physical activity varies over a period of five weeks.
Social Cognitive Theory was useful in accounting for variance in
physical activity.
The
NOAH Project: New Opportunities to Advance Health
R.
Paul Thomlinson, Cami Stanley, Todd Schaible
Purpose
This
presentation will describe the rationale, structure, and initial
outcomes of the NOAH Project (New Opportunities to Advance Health),
a two-year system intervention under way at Cox Health Systems (CHS)
in Springfield, Missouri.
Framework
Our
assertion is that it should be as easy for a physician's office
to schedule a patient for a health education opportunity as it is
to schedule a patient for an imaging procedure or lab work-particularly
if such offerings have been shown through research to reduce health
care costs, enhance health outcomes, and dramatically improve patient
satisfaction. A system which achieves this goal has much potential
to ameliorate the fragmentation, disruptions, and discontinuity
of care often experienced by patients and providers in both managed
care and more traditional health care arrangements.
Overview
The
presentation will cover background information and rationale for
the project, including such findings as these: (1) conventional
clinical activities (eg, diagnostic testing) may be of less value
to patients than activities once considered outside the traditional
role of the physician (eg, patient counseling and education), (2)
one of the initial tasks of the physician practicing in this mode
is shifting control to the patient, and (3) among the most effective
interventions available to clinicians for reducing the incidence
and severity of the leading causes of disease and disability are
those that address the personal health practices of patients. Additionally,
while health care organizations once focused almost exclusively
on helping people overcome illness or injury, on helping patients
get well; the focus is of necessity shifting to encompass both,
get well and stay well, activities. Beneficially, parallel with
this shift in focus of providers, has been a growing consumer interest
in fitness, self-help, nutrition, health education, and alternative
therapies. And, improvement in patient outcomes and cost offset
effects represent compelling reasons for the systematic provision
and coordination of a system-wide patient and family education initiative,
including the outpatient population. The studies supporting this
premise are voluminous, and cover nearly every major cause of disease
and disability known to us (eg, asthma, arthritis, cancer, cardiac
care, diabetes, etc.). While CHS has the aforementioned wide array
of health education services available, with potential for even
greater diversity of offerings, not enough has been done to make
available these important tools for physicians to extend and enhance
patient outcomes by providing their patients with education and
guidance regarding self-help and health maintenance.
Conclusions
In
late 1998, CHS was awarded a small grant from the Burrell Foundation
to initiate activities to achieve integration of supply and need
for health education interventions. Principles, action plans, and
personnel are in place for the system-wide coordination of need
and resources. Further, a comprehensive evaluative study of the
outcomes of this initiative, particularly at the interface of the
patient-provider relationship, is ongoing. The basic objectives
for this research include evaluating the implementation and outcomes
of a coordinated education initiative, with regard to patient health
status improvement, self-efficacy enhancement, and health care resource
utilization. This paper will provide a detailed look at all aspects
of the NOAH Project, including initial outcomes data from the Chronic
Disease Self-Management Program.
Top
Validity
and Reliability of a Self-Regulation for Physical Activity Instrument
Rick
A. Petosa, Cheryl McGaha
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to develop a valid and reliable self-report
instrument to measure the constructs of self-regulation theory as
they pertain to physical activity behavior among adults. The description
of Bandura's self-regulation theory provided the conceptual foundation
used during item development.
Methods
A
40-item research instrument was developed through three stages.
In the first, face and content validity was established through
a two-stage expert review process. During the second, the instrument
was pilot tested on 122 adults and established as a reliable measure
(internal consistency, =.90 and stability coefficient, r=.86). In
the third stage a random sample of 236 adults employed at a large
university in the Midwest completed the instrument through mail
survey. This sample was used to test the construct validity of the
instrument via factor analysis.
Results
Factor
analysis revealed an eight-factor solution represented by the 40-item
instrument: 1) Denial of rewards for failing to exercise as intended,
2) Written recordings of exercise, 3) Disappointment for failing
to exercise as intended, 4) Mental processes associated with exercise
performance and goals, 5) Written setting of goals for exercise,
6) Self rewards for exercise, 7) Bad feelings associated with exercise,
and 8) Good feelings associated with exercise. Each of the factors
was supported as stable, and items making up the factors were established
as internally consistent indicators (indexes ranging from =.88 to
=.97). Hierarchical multiple regression analyses revealed that 17%
(F=10.10, p<.05) of the variance in moderate physical exercise
and 19% (F=10.77, p<.05) of the variance in vigorous physical
exercise was uniquely associated with self-regulation constructs.
Conclusions
The
study produced a valid and reliable measure of self-regulation strategies
for physical activity. This instrument should be tested against
other determinants of physical activity among adults.
Values
Orientation and Health Behaviors among Adolescents in an alternative
high school in New Mexico
Keely
S. Rees, Sharon Thompson
Purpose
This
study was designed to identify the relationship between values orientation
and health-compromising behaviors. Two research questions were used:
(1) Will adolescents with a societal, future-based values orientation
report participation in fewer health-compromising behaviors than
those with a present, self-interest-based values orientation? (2)
Among the high-risk adolescents, will there be a significant relationship
between values orientation and the four most prevalent health-compromising
behaviors?
Methods
This
descriptive study used inferential statistics and correlational
survey methods. The population included students attending an alternative
high school in New Mexico. Forty students, 15-20 years of age, completed
a combined survey that determined their value orientation and their
past health-compromising behaviors. The instrument included six
demographic questions, a modified Youth Risk Behavior Survey, and
the Rokeach Values Survey.
Results
An
ANOVA was selected to test the differences of the values orientation
and health-compromising behaviors among the adolescents. The data
for the first research question posed was not found statistically
significant. The second research question was addressed by running
a Spearman rho rank correlation on the overall risk-taking behavior
category (low, medium, and high risk) and the four health-compromising
behaviors risk classification and were not found statistically significant.
There was a significant relationship (r=.288; p=<.05) found between
violent and unsafe sexual practices using a one-tailed test.
Conclusions
The
most prevalent problems reported for youth in rural New Mexico are
drinking alcohol, physical violence, and other behavioral problems
("Study: Rural teens," 1993). Based on the previous literature,
however, the results of these adolescents' value orientations and
health risk did not concur with what others have hypothesized about
`high-risk' populations. The nature of this study's results may
have interesting implications for future research with similar populations.
Top
Relationship
of Age-Grade Status Congruency And Health Risk Behaviors in High
School Students: An Analysis of 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey
Data
Teresa
J. Byrne, Laurie M. Yoo, Deborah D. Shama
Purpose
The
purpose of this study is to examine the relationship between age-grade
status congruency and six categories of risk behaviors (behavIors
that contribute to unintentional and intentional injuries, tobacco
use, alcohol and other drug use, sexual behaviors, unhealthy dietary
behaviors, and physical inactivity).
Methods
By
combining two variables(age and grade)as collected on the 1997 YRBS
for high school students, three age-grade status groups were established:
age-grade congruent and age-grade incongruent (overage and underage).
A series of four-way analyses of variance were used to analyze the
differences on the risk behaviors among age-grade status groups,
actual grade, and the demographic characteristics of gender and
ethnicity.
Results
The
results showed that there were significant differences between age-grade
congruent and age-grade incongruent students on a number of health
behaviors, particularly in the areas of unintentional and intentional
injuries, tobacco use, alcohol and other drug use, and sexual behaviors.
Furthermore, differences were found for actual grade, gender, and
ethnicity. Numerous interactions were also obtained.
Conclusions
The
practices of delayed and early school entry, as well as grade retention
and acceleration, are based on incomplete and inconsistent data
gained primarily through research on the early grades and on academic
achievement. Findings from the YRBS indicate that the age-grade
status congruency in high school has significant implications for
behavioral risk factors. These findings support the seminal work
of Byrd, Weitzman, and Doniger (1996) and the earlier work of Peterson
and Crockett (1985) and add to this fairly meager body of research.
The
Protective Role of Decision Making Skill Level in the Relationship
between Socioeconomic Status and Rural Adolescent Smoking
Kimberly
L. Henry, Daphne Minner, Judith Vicary, Lori Bechtel
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was twofold. The first objective was to investigate
the ability of poor emotional tone and positive attitudes(believes
substance use has benefits) toward alcohol, tobacco and other drug
(ATOD) use to mediate the relationship between low socioeconomic
status (SES) and rural adolescent smoking. Secondly, to investigate
the protective role of high level decision-making ability.
Methods
The
data for this study were taken from the ADAPT project, a five year
program funded by NIDA. The first wave of data for 711 7th graders
in nine rural Pennsylvania schools was used. The hypotheses were
tested using structural equation modeling.
Results
The
overall direct effect of low SES leading to increased incidence
of smoking was significant. SES was also found to be a significant
predictor of emotional tone and positive attitudes toward ATOD.
In addition, a positive attitude toward ATOD was found to be a significant
mediator between SES and smoking. Path differences for good compared
to poor decision makers revealed that the relationship between SES
and smoking status and positive attitude and smoking status was
significantly stronger for the poor decision makers.
Conclusions
These
results support previous findings suggesting that lower SES adolescents
are more likely to possess a positive attitude toward ATOD and use
substances than their non-rural peers are. This study found that
decision making skill level can partially buffer this relationship,
suggesting that increasing cognitive behavioral skills such as decision
making may help to delay the initiation of smoking.
Top
The
Relationship between Exercise Self-efficacy and the Stages of Behavior
Change in College Students
Bradley
R. A. Wilson, Amy E. Pawlak, Amy L. Bernard
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between exercise
self-efficacy and an individual's stage of change as related to
exercise behavior among college students.
Methods
A
questionnaire containing several self-efficacy scales (assessment,
expectation, and outcome), a perceived health scale, and a stage
of scale was distributed to 733 college students.
Results
Results
indicated a significant relationship between exercise self-efficacy
and stage of change, assessment r=.245 (p<.0001), expectation
r=.554 (p<.0001), and outcome r=.245 (p<.0001). As the stage
of change increased toward maintenance, self-efficacy also increased.
An ANOVA demonstrated significant differences in self-efficacy scores
based on the stage of change: assessment (F(4,728)=55.56, p<.0001),
expectation (F(4,728)=82.33, p<.0001), and outcome (F(4,728)=12.01,
p<.0001). A Scheffe' post hoc found no differences between the
stages precontemplation and contemplation, or preparation and action
for the assessment sub-scale. The maintenance stage was significantly
different from the other four stages. For the sub-scale expectation
all five groups were significantly different from one another. The
outcome sub-scale showed the most similarities. A Pearson Correlation
found perceived health was positively correlated with stage of change,
r=.497 (p<.0001).
Conclusions
These
data are useful for targeting students with exercise information
based on the individual's stage of change status. Since students
at different stages of change have different self-efficacy for exercise,
program promotional materials targeted at specific stages of change
may be warranted.
Using
Theoretical Constructs in the Conceptualization and Development
of a Curriculum
Stephen
Nagy, Leslie F. Clark
Purpose
To
share the methodology of curriculum design employing a theoretical
framework.
Framework
A
developmental, strength-based curriculum to reduce at-risk behaviors
for students in grades 6, 7, and 8 utilized the Theory of Possible
Selves and Health Education Theory to conceptualize a 20-day curriculum
for each grade level. Constructs from Possible Selves, might become,
hope to become, and afraid to become were blended with the two main
health education approaches; risk reduction and growth (Wellness).
Overview
The
methodology incorporated a three-stage process. Stage one involved
the development of the main themes of the curricula as well as the
unit themes. This was based on the theoretical constructs. The second
stage determined the emphasis of the theoretical constructs within
the curricula. The third stage was the development of actual lesson
plans through the use of social learning activities.
Conclusions
The
development of an intervention should be theoretically driven and
theory should be applied in the conceptualization of curriculum
materials, unit development and individual lessons. This process
will ensure that day-to-day activities in the program will address
the program objectives.
Top
Association
Between Exercise and Quality of Life in a Population-based Sample
Natalie
Colabianchi, Elaine A. Borawski
Purpose
To
explore the association between exercise and quality of life (QoL)
(ie, number of days of depression, sleeplessness, anxiety, pain,
and vitality in the past thirty days) using a population-based sample
of adults, aged 18 years and older.
Methods
Data
from the 1998 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS)
were used. Exercise questions are included in an optional
module and therefore only 14 states participated (N=42,631). Exercise
was defined as physical activity for at least 20 minutes/3 times
a week. Regression models were used to examine the primary association
between exercise and QoL. In addition, the study examined
interactions between exercise and three major covariates, self-reported
health, age and gender. Additional covariates included education,
employment and race, however their interaction with exercise was
not examined. Separate models were run for each of the five
outcomes for those in excellent-good health and fair-poor health.
Adjusted means and 99% confidence intervals were calculated for
each model. Due to the large sample size and number of analyses,
non-overlapping 99% confidence intervals for the adjusted means
were used to designate significant differences between exercisers
and non-exercisers. Analyses were performed using STATA (release
6) to account for the sampling design and the use of clustering
and stratification.
Results
In
the multivariate analyses, exercise was significantly associated
with three of the five quality of life measures including depression,
pain, and vitality. Stratified analyses demonstrated that the
benefit of exercise varied by age, gender and/or self-reported health
for four of the five quality of life measures (depression, pain,
sleeplessness, and vitality).
Conclusions
Identification
of life-style behaviors that increase quality of life is an important
part in reaching the goals for Healthy People 2010. This study
shows that exercise is associated with higher quality of life for
those in excellent-good health as well as for those in fair-poor
health and that exercise may be particularly important for older
adults.
Substantiating
Pregnancy Risk Factors for Adolescent Males
Stephen
Nagy, Christine Nagy, Graham Watts
Purpose
To
examine pregnancy risk factors for adolescent males and identify
a theoretical framework for future intervention.
Methods
Data
were obtained from the 1998 Alabama Adolescent Survey, a paper and
pencil measure that utilized 8 school districts. Approximately 2200
students completed the survey. 931 male Caucasian and African-Americans
completed the survey item asking whether the student had caused
a pregnancy or thought they had done so. Logistic regression was
used with the dependent measure, 4 violence measures, 3 drug use
measures, one academic aspiration item, and two items on friends.
Results
Demographic
and peer measures were modest predictors with significant odds ratios
(OR) below 2. Academic aspirations were good predictors (OR=3.7).
The best predictors were substance use and violence measures with
OR between 4 and 8.
Conclusions
Jessor's
theory of problem behaviors predicts that problem behaviors are
inter-related. Conceptually this implies intervention addressing
multiple risky behaviors and their antecedents. The data from this
study support problem behavior theory in that, risky behavioral
items were powerfully linked with having caused a pregnancy. Demographic,
items on peers and academic aspiration variables did not have the
same predictive power. This has major implications for pregnancy
prevention interventions designed for males. Programs need to identify
at risk students and address the cluster of risky behaviors to impact
on pregnancy prevention. A "one size fits all" approach
is unlikely to succeed.
Top
Feasibility
of Virtual Health & Wellness Center
Catherine
Salveson, Deborah C. Messecar
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to examine the feasibility of implementing
a virtual health and wellness center in the Oregon Air National
Guard (ORANG) The specific aims of the study were to describe Air
Guard Members goals for making health behavior changes and their
preferred formats for receiving information that will assist them.
Methods
A
survey was constructed with ORANG member focus group input. The
survey asked about the health behaviors members wanted to change,
and explored their current access to, and use of the Internet to
make these changes. Surveys were mailed to 1,368 persons, and 540
surveys were returned for a response rate of approximately 40%.
Results
89%
of respondents answered that they had thought of making one or more
health behavior changes in the past year. Among those that had contemplated
making changes, the most popular change was becoming more physically
active (94.6%) followed by improving eating habits (86%), or losing
weight (81%), and improving stress management (62%) and reduction
of tobacco use (46%). Popular sources of health behavior change
information used included reading material (95.5%) and the Internet
(91.3%). Health care providers were the most important resource
participants reported using (90%) when seeking personal service
help with making a behavior change.
Conclusions
According
to the respondents of this survey, use of the Internet by health
professionals to promote health behavior change seems feasible and
desirable
Oral
Sexual Behavior in Adolescents
Bradley
O. Boekeloo, Donna Howard, Kathy O'Connor
Purpose
Adolescents
are at risk for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) including HIV
through various unsafe sexual behaviors. Most surveys on the sexual
risk behaviors of adolescents are vague in regard to which risk
behaviors are being measured. Oral sexual behaviors are often ignored
in surveys on sexual risk in adolescents. It is not known to what
extent risk identification could be improved if oral sex were measured.
Methods
In
1995, adolescents age 12 through 15 years old were surveyed regarding
their sexual behaviors when they visited their pediatrician for
a general health examination. The survey was part of a larger risk
reduction demonstration project. Study sites were six pediatric
practices in Washington D.C. Adolescents were confidentially administered
questions by a research interviewer about their lifetime involvement
in vaginal and oral sexual behaviors.
Results
Vaginal
intercourse was reported by 24% of adolescents. The rates of passive
and active oral sex, respectively, were 14% and 8% for males vs.
20% and 13% for females. Rates were higher among the older age groups.
Had only vaginal sex been assessed, 4% of adolescents at risk due
to passive oral sex and 3% due to active oral sex would not have
been identified. Again, rates were higher in the older age groups.
Oral sex was associated with other risk behaviors such as alcohol
use.
Conclusions
This
study suggests that young adolescents may be involved in oral sexual
behaviors that may put them at risk for STDs and HIV. Although asking
about specific oral sexual behaviors may be difficult logistically,
politically, and interpersonally, thorough risk assessment may require
this measurement.
Top
The
Influence of Demographic Variables on Stress in Graduate Teaching
Assistants
Maureen
K. Morrissey, Mark J. Kittleson
Purpose
Graduate
students are vulnerable to stress, particularly those employed as
teaching assistants. Teaching assistants (TA's) may be overwhelmed
with having to provide quality instruction to undergraduates while
simultaneously attending to their own academic and professional
growth. Because of these demands, TA's may exhibit physical and
psychological symptoms of stress, possibly resulting in serious
illness. The purpose of this study is to examine the effects of
several demographic variables on stress in graduate teaching assistants.
Methods
The
sample consisted of 515 graduate teaching assistants (TA's) from
a midwest university. The TA's were employed in the College of Liberal
Arts, Education, or Science during the fall 1998 and spring 1999
semesters. Two hundred twelve TA's completed and returned the instrument.
Results
The
resulting probability level of .213 indicated there was no significant
difference in stress between male TA's and female TA's. For the
research question examining ethnicity as a predictor of stress,
the distribution of TA's by ethnic groups were as follows: 11 were
African or African American, 18 were Asian or Asian American, 163
were Caucasian, three were Hispanic, and five described themselves
as "other". An ANOVA was used to compare the stress between
groups. The resulting probability of .173 indicated there was no
significant difference in stress between ethnic groups. Of the participating
TA's, 131 were in the College of Liberal Arts, 24 were in the College
of Education, and 45 were in the College of Science. The resulting
p-value was .48, indicating there was no significant difference
in stress between TA's of different colleges.
Conclusions
Since
there was no significant difference between the two groups, it can
be concluded that both male and female teaching assistants effectively
manage their stress. Also, neither males of females are the dominant
gender, as the number of TA's in both groups is relatively equal.
Although there were no significant differences in stress between
TA's of different ethnic groups, this study considered stress as
subjective and occurring within a time period of one month. However,
the differences in stress may change with the time of the semester,
such as "finals week". Also, differences in stress may
between the different ethnic groups if stress were defined in terms
of specific symptoms or life events rather than as a global, subjective
concept. Regardless of academic college, teaching assistants face
many demands in their dual roles as student and educator. This may
account for the similarity in stress between teaching assistants
of different academic colleges. Although academic colleges other
than education employed many teaching assistants, they may actually
enjoy teaching and may not feel the pressure of working in an environment
they dislike. In conclusion, this study examines the influence of
several demographic variables on stress in graduate teaching assistants.
These demographic variables may compound the difficulties already
faced by teaching assistants, who must excel both as students and
educators. Additional studies predicting stress in teaching assistants
should be conducted, as stress that is not effectively managed can
result in inferior instruction for undergraduates and in serious
illness for the teaching assistants themselves.
Effectiveness
of AbstinenceOnly and SaferSex Curricula Among Middle School Adolescents
Elaine
A. Borawski, Loren Lovegreen, Carolyn Tung, Katy Abbott
Purpose
To
examine the effectiveness of two alternative HIV prevention curricula
taught in six urban middle schools: abstinenceonly (focus
on benefits of abstinence until marriage) and safersex (focus
on condoms and building negotiation and resistance skills). A pair
of schools each received one of the intervention curricula, the
remaining pair served as controls (received delayed intervention).
The goal of the study was to determine whether interventionexposed
students would report changes in knowledge, efficacy, beliefs, peer
norms, intentions and sexual activity, when compared to a control
group and to each other.
Methods
A
total of 910 8th graders completed a pretest and 12week
posttest (72% followup): 378 (42%) received the safersex curriculum,
280 (31%) received the abstinenceonly curriculum, and 252 (28%)
served as controls. Followed students were significantly more likely
to be younger, female and less sexually experienced at baseline
than those not followed.
Results
Multivariate
analyses examined the change in cognitive and behavioral outcomes,
controlling for baseline measures of the outcome, demographics and
prior sexual experience. When compared to controls, students from
both interventions demonstrated increases in knowledge, abstinence
beliefs, and efficacy to resist sexual advances. SS students demonstrated
an increase in condomuse efficacy while AO students showed a decrease.
However, AO students reported lower sexual intentions, and were
marginally less likely (p=0.06) to have sex during the evaluation
period. These behavioral results were more pronounced among female
and sexually inexperienced students than males or those sexually
experienced prior to the intervention.
Conclusions
While
both interventions had an effect on knowledge, attitudes, and efficacy,
the AO program had a more consistent effect (albeit short term)
on intentions and behavior. However, due to the low condomuse efficacy
in the AO group, there is concern that these students will be at
higher risk when they initiate sexual activity in the future.
Top
Social
Support and Prenatal Care on the U.S./Mexico Border
Sharon
E. Thompson, Keely S. Rees
Purpose
The
purpose of the study was to gather information about perceived satisfaction
of social support during pregnancy and participation in prenatal
care.
Methods
The
proposed research method for this study was a cross sectional survey.
A convenience sample of 106 participants was obtained at four Special
Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children
(WIC) sites in El Paso, Texas.
The
research question examined for this study, will there be a difference
between mean social support scores and level of prenatal care among
participating women, was explored by a one-way analysis of variance.
The alpha level for detecting statistically significant mean differences
for this study was set at p<0.05.
Results
A
significant difference between mean social support scores and level
of prenatal care was found to exist. The Social Support Apgar Score
(SSAS) for participants varied significantly with the level of prenatal
care (F =4.175, df=2, 89, p<0.05). The mean SSAS for women of
inadequate prenatal care was 24.2500 (n=16). The mean SSAS of participants
of intermediate prenatal care was 22.0909 (n=11), and the mean SSAS
of women with adequate levels of prenatal care was 30.5692 (n= 65).
Conclusions
Women
who reported receiving social support in the form of adaptation,
partnership, growth, affection, and resolve/commitment, reported
adequate prenatal care. More supportive environments may be more
conducive in overcoming obstacles that could impede the acquisition
of adequate prenatal care.
Social
support programs continue to be a simple and cost-effective method
of improving various health outcomes, including but not limited
to birth and natality outcomes. Based on the present study and existing
maternal and child health literature, it would appear to be reasonable
for facilities and agencies working with pregnant women to administer
the Social Support Apgar or like-instrument so that estimates of
social support, as an important variable in birth outcomes, can
be documented. Women reporting low-levels of informal social support
could be directed to an agency-sponsored formal social support network
Sexual
Self-Disclosure: What We Tell, What We Don't Tell and Why
Margit
B. Gerardi, Andrea Berndt
Purpose
Don't
ask and don't tell may or may not work in the military, but adolescents
must learn how to disclose and inquire about their sexual history
and that of potential partners. To date, research has primarily
examined adult self-disclosure in friendships, with strangers, and
within relationships including physical intimacy. Less is known
about adolescent sexual self-disclosure in general. Beyond that,
unique factors that explain adolescent sexual self-disclosure such
as peer pressure, values, and developing morality need to be explored.
Methods
Established
surveys were used to assess adolescent disclosure, demographics,
and characteristics such as age and education. New surveys were
developed to examine adolescent perceptions about appropriate sexual
practices as well as their self-reported corresponding behaviors.
Results
Factor
analysis indicated some unique adolescent self-disclosure patterns.
However, results also support some similarities to previously published
adult disclosure. A MANOVA indicated females were more likely than
males to disclose perceptions of appropriate practices. Further,
the MANOVA results suggested disclosure increased with age and was
influenced by acculturation. Finally, a discriminant function analysis
reveals specific patterns of actual behaviors and perceptions that
reliably separated adolescents.
Conclusions
This
study indicates that adolescent self-disclosure in some ways is
different from adult self-disclosure. Health care professionals
can benefit from this information by tailoring health and educational
interventions to adolescents. Finally, this research may have interdisciplinary
value that provides shared relevance for professionals from clinical,
community, health care, and academic settings.
Top
Construct
Validation of a Four-Session Worksite Intervention on Selected Social
Cognitive Theory Variables Linked to Adult Exercise Adherence
Jeffrey
S. Hallam, Rick Petosa
Purpose
Exercise
interventions delivered at the worksite have produced inconsistent
results. While some studies produced modest, short-term increases
in exercise behavior, other studies produced little effect. It is
suggested that the careful use of behavioral theories can increase
the effectiveness of health promotion programs. In response, many
worksite interventions now claim to be based on theory. Yet, a careful
reading of these articles makes it difficult to determine precisely
how theories are incorporated into the intervention. Most important,
few of these evaluations have documented the impact of the intervention
on targeted theoretical constructs. The purpose of this study was
to test the construct validity of a four-session worksite exercise
intervention on selected Social Cognitive Theory variables linked
to adult exercise adherence. The Social Cognitive Theory variables
measured were exercise self-efficacy, outcome-expectancy values
for exercise and the use of self-regulation skills for exercise.
The intervention was designed to produce enduring changes in the
Social Cognitive Theory variables. Ergo, observations were collected
at six weeks, six months, and 12 months. Testing construct validity
of the treatment establishes a foundation upon which causal linkages
between theoretical variables and subsequent exercise behavior can
be based.
Methods
To
recruit participants into the experimental group, a two-page flyer
was distributed to all employees of a service-type industry (N=7,000).
The flyer promoted an exercise class for employees that wanted to
begin exercising or had just begun and needed help to stay with
their program. The exercise stages-of-change instrument was used
to screen employees into the study. If employees were categorized
in the Contemplation, Preparation, or Action stages, they were eligible
for enrollment. Five hundred and ninety-eight employees returned
an enrollment form and an exercise stages-of-change instrument.
The first 60 employees that met the selection criteria were notified
through interoffice mail of confirmation of enrollment in the class.
The comparison group was formed by randomly selecting 120 employees
that joined the company's fitness center no longer than 30 days
before the beginning of the intervention. This group was chosen
to compare the theory-based intervention with the program that was
normally offered to employees that join the fitness center. The
treatment group was formed by self-selection and equivalency between
the treatment group and the comparison group cannot be assumed.
Therefore, a nonequivalent pretest/posttest design was employed
with observations made at six weeks, six months, and 12 months.
Three SCT variables were measured for all observations: (1) outcome-expectancy
value, (2) exercise self-efficacy, and (3) the use of self-regulation
strategies for exercise. Each instrument used in this study had
established reliability and validity.
Results
Only
those participants that completed all four observations were included
in the analysis. The results show a significant increase in the
use of self-regulation for exercise from pretest to posttest. The
treatment group was able to maintain the use of the self-regulation
skills over 12 months. There was no difference between the groups
on self-regulation for the pretest, but the treatment group increased
their use of self-regulation strategies and maintained that use
while the comparison group continued to decrease in their use of
self-regulation strategies. No significant increase in exercise
self-efficacy was found. No significant differences in Social Cognitive
Theory variables were detected for the comparison group. Each Social
Cognitive Theory variable score decreased for the comparison group
for all posttest observations except for self-efficacy which increased
one point from the six-week posttest to the six-month posttest.
Outcome expectancy-value changed significantly from the pretest
to posttest for the treatment group. When outcome expectations and
outcome expectancies were examined independently, the results showed
a statistically significant increase for outcome expectations for
the treatment group, but no statistically significant difference
for outcome expectancies.
Conclusions
This
study shows that selected Social Cognitive Theory variables are
changeable in a relatively brief intervention. Specifically, the
use of self-regulation techniques to support regular exercise was
found amenable to change. The intervention provides a model program
of how to elicit changes in self-regulation techniques and outcome
expectancy-value (specifically outcome expectations). The intervention
was a classroom-based program that produced statistically significant
changes in two of three selected Social Cognitive Theory variables.
The comparison group reported small, non-significant decreases in
all Social Cognitive Theory variables measured in this study. The
comparison group received a program of assessment, instruction and
access to facilities, which is common to many worksite based fitness
promotion programs. Clearly, this approach did not have a favorable
impact on psychosocial variables associated with exercise adherence.
These results may be explained by a reevaluation of beliefs and
perceived capabilities to exercise once faced with the real experiences
related to the adoption of an exercise program. This observation
warrants further study. With the limited contact hours health promotion
specialists have with employees, this intervention shows that a
short-term intervention can be successful in changing self-regulation
skills and outcome-expectancy values. Future research should examine
what level of use of self-regulation skills and what level of outcome-expectancy
values are necessary and sufficient for the adoption and maintenance
of exercise behavior. Moreover, future research should study the
relationship between changes in theoretical variables and subsequent
changes in exercise behavior.
Top
How
Alienation and Declines in Social Capital are Affecting Adolescent
Well-being
Donna
E. Howard
Purpose
Social
indicators suggest a rise in alienation and decline in social capital.
How these affect personal and collective well being is examined,
with specific reference to U.S. adolescents.
Framework
Sociologic
constructs such as social integration, social capital, and alienation
are integrated with interpersonal health behavior theories to model
pathways by which youth either disengage from the social fabric
of society or engage in subcultures that promote risk and anti-social
behavior, such as violence.
Overview
For
poor, urban, minority families the pronounced and widening gap in
the distribution of income and other resources may give rise to
social disorganization, low social cohesion, and perceptions of
marginalization. It is within this context that youth attempt to
realize developmental goals such as mastery, self-esteem and self-identity.
The destabilizing effects of such inequities allow violence and
other forms of antisocial and delinquent behavior to flourish and
may lead to the experience of hopelessness and despair. For suburban
higher income youth, the increase in dual working parent households
has lead to a growing number of adolescents in unsupervised activities
with declining adult contact, supervision and guidance. This may
lead some youth to experiment with risk behaviors, and others to
explore internet sites which, while appealing to youthful desires
for connection and validation, espouse hate and violence.
Conclusions
Social
integration at the personal and community level is an important
protective factor for adolescent well being.
Why
Girls Smoke: A Community-based, Peer-led Program: Helping Each Other
Resist Smoking (HERS)
Mary
Ann Faucher, Sherry Carter
Purpose
The
purpose of this project is to review literature findings related
to why teenaged girls begin to smoke. In addition, evidence about
smoking prevention program's strengths and weaknesses is summarized
and incorporated into a new and innovative smoking prevention program
specifically targeted at teenaged girls ages 13 to 15. The poster
will highlight the evidence and describe a community-based, peer-led
smoking prevention program, The HERS (Help Each Other Resist Smoking)
Program, which is based on research findings and constructs of the
theory of reasoned action and the theory of planned behavior.
Framework
Ajzen
and Fishbein's (1986) theory of reasoned action and theory of planned
behavior is particularly suitable for a successful smoking prevention
program designed specifically for adolescent girls. This theory
matches well with the knowledge that females are more likely to
report social norms and peer pressure as reasons to initiate smoking
as compared to their male counterparts (Sarason, et al. 1992). In
addition, the construct of behavioral beliefs provides the avenue
for addressing the strong association between weight control and
perceived body image as reasons young women report for initiating
and continuing smoking (Hynes, 1989).
Moreover,
the model constructs of perceived behavioral control and perceived
power can be applied to develop aspects of the program that will
increase the young women's feelings of accomplishment and self-respect
(eg, physical fitness and cooking classes). Both constructs have
been demonstrated to be inversely related to smoking in young women
(Allen, Leadbeater, and Aber, 1990; Clayton, 1991; Grube et al.,
1984; Hynes, 1989). Battjes's (1985) four-fold classification system
provided the framework for developing methods suitable for social-influence
programs and Atkinson's (1964) third principle of motivation, the
value of incentive, is included in both phase I and phase II of
the HERS program.
Overview
A
large suburban community with an organized program of recreation
centers is the location of this proposed smoking prevention program.
The program consists of 2 phases, each one year in length. Behavioral
and normative beliefs elucidated in focus groups will be used to
design program content. In addition, recommendations from the 1987
expert advisory panel of The National Cancer Institute will be incorporated.
In Phase II, relapse prevention, evidence obtained from the literature
guides development of multimedia strategies.
Conclusions
Recent
statistics demonstrate the rising use of cigarettes in young women
along with the proportional increase in morbidity and mortality
in girls that smoke (ACS, 1997). This combination clearly merits
a focused and gender specific approach towards prevention. The evidence
suggests that prevention programs with strong social influence components
directly target the reasons girls initiate smoking. Ajzen and Fishbein's
theory of reasoned action provides a suitable framework and the
incentives enhance motivation. Structured classroom time with role-playing
is intended to influence attitudes toward the behavior of smoking.
Reasonable target goals for physical fitness and opportunities to
practice healthy eating should instill feelings of accomplishment
and provide healthy substitutes to smoking. This program, in entirety,
should increase the likelihood of the participants moving into a
phase of planned behavior, which is to resist smoking.
Top
Integrating
Substance Abuse Prevention and Health Promotion: Ten Years of Research
James
V. Trudeau, Royer F. Cook
Purpose
This
presentation describes a program of research showing that integrating
substance abuse prevention into workplace-based health promotion
enhances the former without diluting the latter. A sophisticated
yet practical social-learning approach raises awareness, knowledge
and motivation about health and substance use while bolstering needed
skills. Five studies conducted in varied industries over ten years
are summarized.
Methods
The
studies used rigorous research designs and methods, including random
assignment to condition (intervention/comparison), staggered implementation
in which comparison subjects subsequently received the intervention,
and sophisticated multivariate analysis of pre/post data. Settings
included manufacturing (evaluation of the SAY YES! program), publishing
(Working People program), construction (Power Tools program) and
insurance (Connections and Prime Life 2000 programs). Participants
completed confidential Health Behavior Questionnaires addressing
attitudes, behavioral intentions and behaviors related to various
aspects of substance use, health and behavioral health. The latest
study included human resources data (eg, employee performance ratings)
and healthcare claims data.
Results
Workplace-based
health promotion activities were shown to improve various health-related
outcomes, including perceived health control, health behaviors,
stress management, and healthy eating. Moreover, subjects receiving
integrated substance abuse prevention materials improved relative
to comparison subjects on outcomes including perceived risks, substance
use to relieve stress, and alcohol use. One study found increased
post-intervention utilization of behavioral healthcare.
Conclusion
Integrating
substance abuse prevention into workplace-based health promotion
increases participation and provides a context for discussing the
connections between substance use and health. This approach offers
considerable promise for reaching millions of working adults with
substance abuse prevention messages and materials. This is an important
point because the majority of substance abusers are working adults,
and workplace programs are the best way to reach them.
An
Evaluation of an Abstinence Education Curriculum Series
Michael
E. Young, George Denny, Susan Rausch, Caile Spear
Purpose
The
purpose of the study was to examine the effects of an abstinence
education curriculum series on student outcomes, including measures
of sexual behavior.
Methods
The
curriculum was taught by trained school personnel at three levels:
upper elementary, junior high and high school. Project staff administered
a questionnaire to all students before the curriculum was implemented
and after completion of the curriculum six weeks to two months later.
Comparison group students also completed the questionnaire at the
same times, but did not participate in the curriculum. The analysis
was based on 386 upper elementary students, 698 junior high school
students, and 337 high school students. Data were analyzed using
ANCOVA, with pretest scores serving as covariates, and logistical
regression.
Results
Upper
elementary - the curriculum group had significantly better outcomes
on knowledge, self-esteem, and self-efficacy. Middle school - no
significant differences between the two groups. High School - findings
favored the curriculum group on attitude, intent to remain abstinent,
and on the sexual behavior variables (sexual intercourse ever and
sexual intercourse in the last month).
Conclusion
Results
indicated that the high school program may be of benefit in helping
young people abstain from sexual intercourse. We did not expect
behavior change to occur at any grade level during the relatively
short time from pre-test to posttest. That such changes were noted
at the high school level is encouraging. Long-term follow-up is
needed to determine the effect of the program on the behavior of
the younger students.
Top
Risk
Factors as Predictors of Adolescent Alcohol Involvement
Michael
S. Dunn, Chudley E. Werch
Purpose
The
purpose of this study was to determine predictors of three alcohol
use measures (ever tried, stage of initiation, and current use)
among middle school students.
Methods
Data
were obtained from a three-wave cohort of sixth - eighth grade students
participating in a school-based alcohol use prevention program.
From the Fall of 1996 to the Spring of 1998, 650 students completed
the Youth Alcohol and Drug Survey. This instrument measures alcohol
and drug consumption and alcohol-related cognitive, social and behavioral
risk and protective factors. Linear Regression analysis procedures
were used to determine predictors of the dependent variables: 1)
ever tried alcohol, 2) stage of initiation, and 3) current use alcohol
use.
Results
Results
of this study found that risk factors tended to increase as students
progressed to higher grade levels. Mother's alcohol use, situation,
emotional coping, and environmental influencibilty were found to
be strongly predictive of ever tried alcohol among seventh and eighth
graders. Emotional coping, cigarette use, and marijuana use were
found to be predictive of stage of initiation and current use among
seventh and eighth graders.
Conclusions
Risk
factors were found to increase with grade level, as such preventive
efforts should be designed to provide support on how to effectively
deal with peer pressure. As students progress to higher grades,
they are faced with more peer pressure and influencing factors.
Students need to be taught strategies that reinforce developmentally
appropriate skills that enhance personal competency as effective
barriers against risk factors.
Body
Weight and Physical Activity Levels in Cancer Patients Undergoing
Elective Hip Surgery: Implications for Prevention and Rehabilitation
Sandra
G. Avila, Ray Marks, John P. Allegrante
Purpose
To
evaluate whether patients with a past history of cancer, undergoing
total hip arthroplasty (THA), would be overweight and have lower
physical capacity compared to patients undergoing THA with no history
of cancer.
Methods
Body
Mass Indices (BMI's) and Ideal Weights of 95 individuals with a
cancer history undergoing THA were compared to 55 THA patients in
the same age range, with no cancer history. Pre and post-surgical
physical capacity as indicated by measures of walking distance was
also assessed.
Results
Analysis
of medical records showed that: 1) 66.3% of 95 THA patients with
a cancer history were overweight or obese, a figure comparable to
those without any disease, where weight may be a risk factor. 2)
THA patients with a cancer history had a lower physical capacity
immediately before and after surgery compared to THA patients with
a cancer history.
Conclusion
Excess
body weight and low physical capacity, which are implicated factors
for cancer and osteoarthritis, are common findings in cancer survivors
undergoing THA for painful hip arthritis. This finding has not previously
been reported, and has important public health and clinical implications.
Top
Reviewers:
Gregory
H. Frazer
Elbert D. Glover
Patricia Mail
Robert J. McDermott
Cheryl J. Rainey
Marjorie E. Scaffa
Dennis L. Thombs
Robert F. Valois
Robert M. Weiler
Michael Young
Am J Health
Behav 2001;25(4):318-341
|